Most nonprofits start looking for event software at one of two points. Either they're running their first real fundraiser, or their renewal is coming up and something about last year still bothers them.
The first group writes requirements from the event plan. The second writes them from whatever went wrong last year.
Both routes lead to the same place. You end up comparing platforms that look similar on a features page and work quite differently in practice.
Pledge It and GiveSmart are two of them. The features overlap enough to make the choice look easy, but how each one is packaged makes a real difference for a fundraising team.
Here is how the two compare on features and pricing, along with a few other GiveSmart alternatives worth knowing about.
Are Pledge It and GiveSmart in the Same Category?
Yes, both are fundraising software for nonprofits, covering ticketing, auctions, sponsorships, and peer-to-peer campaigns.
The difference is emphasis. GiveSmart focuses on ticketed events and auctions. Pledge It covers every type of fundraising a nonprofit runs, and does each one well, without splitting the work across separate tools.
What is Pledge It?
Best for: Small to midsize teams running a signature annual event on participant recruitment and sponsor revenue. Sponsor packages, P2P, and year-round giving all come under one subscription.
More than 2,000 nonprofits use Pledge It to run their fundraising events.

Tickets, sponsor packages, participant pages, the auction, and reporting all live on the same dashboard. Your team never has to pull data from one tool to check it against another.
Repeat events get real attention here. Last year's participants and donors carry into this year's campaign, which gives teams a ready audience to reach out to.
Key Features of Pledge It
- Events and ticketing with registration, table seating, attendee tracking, and live donation displays
- Peer-to-peer fundraising with personal and team pages, leaderboards, and social sharing
- Endurance fundraising for walks, runs, rides, and multi-week challenges
- Sponsorships you can sell, track, and fulfill, with tickets allocated automatically
- Silent auctions and raffles
- A merchandise shop and Fund a Need, both available as Power-Ups
- Donation forms, recurring giving, and crowdfunding pages
- Year-over-year analytics with automated recruiting of past participants
- Branded tax receipts and built-in gift matching
- A dedicated Customer Success Manager on annual plans
Worth Knowing: Pledge It is for US-based fundraising only. Also, you can integrate it with the CRM you already use.
What is GiveSmart?
Best for: Nonprofits, schools, and foundations whose fundraising centers on a large auction night, particularly teams that also want donor management from the same vendor.
GiveSmart covers auctions, ticketing, online giving, peer-to-peer campaigns, and donor management. The company started in 2011 and built its reputation on mobile bidding.
It took shape through acquisitions. GiveSmart, 501 Auctions, and Gesture were brought under one owner in 2018, with MobileCause added in 2021 and SimplyFundraisingCRM in 2022.
In 2024, private equity firm TA Associates acquired the parent company's nonprofit and association divisions, forming Momentive Software.
GiveSmart belongs to that group and runs separate logins for Events, Fundraise, and Donor CRM.

Key Features
- Mobile bidding for silent, live, and hybrid auctions
- Ticketing and guest management
- Event-day tools
- Peer-to-peer campaigns
- Raffles, voting, fixed-price items
- Virtual and hybrid formats with livestream and proxy bidding
- Embeddable donation forms, recurring giving, and a donor portal
- Donor CRM for household and group records
- 24/7 support and live event-day assistance
Worth Knowing: Events, Fundraise, and Donor CRM run as separate logins rather than a single dashboard, which is the most common operational complaint from teams running all three. Also only US-focused.
Pledge It vs. GiveSmart: What You Need to Know Upfront
How Pledge It and GiveSmart Compare Across 11 Fundraising Features
Both platforms will get your event online. The differences show up in the work that surrounds it, before and after event day.
1. Events and Ticketing Software
Event and ticketing tools handle the logistics of a fundraising event: selling tickets, managing the guest list, seating tables, and checking people in.
Pledge It: Ticket packages, table seating, attendee tracking, and check-in all come inside the campaign, so your guest list and fundraising totals stay in sync.
A live donation display can run during the event, keeping the room aware of where the number stands.

GiveSmart: Guest management covers seating and group assignment, contactless check-in, and sign-up parties. Guests enter their payment and contact details once, and that carries through the night.
The platform generates tax receipts and thank-you letters, and sponsorships and tables can include custom fields.
Verdict: Close, and it depends on the event. GiveSmart goes deeper on gala-night guest management, with group seating, contactless check-in and sign-up parties. Pledge It covers what most events need, including ticket packages, table seating and check-in, all on the same platform as your other events and fundraisers.
2. Peer-to-Peer Fundraising Platforms
Peer-to-peer (P2P) fundraising is a method in which supporters raise funds for a cause by collecting donations from their friends, family, and contacts.

Pledge It: Participant pages are created at registration. Each page includes photos, a personal story, and a goal the participant sets, and captains manage their teams from the same screen.
A community wall collects everyone's updates into one feed, and custom leaderboards add competition between teams or regions, and a matching gift tool is available when a sponsor wants to multiply what the group raises.
Returning fundraisers keep their past donor lists, which makes the second season easier than the first.
GiveSmart: Supporters build on-brand pages with images, video, and a rich-text editor, updating them from any device. Sign-up happens on the organization's own GiveSmart page.
Teams, progress thermometers, social sharing, text-to-donate keyword, and dashboard reporting are included.
Verdict: Pledge It offers a best-in-class P2P fundraising experience for participants, donors and campaign managers. That removes the activation gap between sign-up and first ask, which is the point where most P2P fundraising software platforms lose participants.
The advantage compounds after year one. Returning fundraisers keep their past donor lists, and the community wall carries the momentum forward.
On the GiveSmart side, the P2P module covers the essentials, and per-participant text-to-donate keywords suit teams that lean on SMS giving.
3. Activity Fundraisers and Endurance Events
Activity fundraising ties donations to something participants do, like miles run, laps swum or steps walked. Endurance fundraising centers on a race, where nonprofits fill guaranteed entries (charity bibs) with runners who commit to raising a set amount.
Pledge It: Activity-based fundraising. Participants track an activity of their choice, whether that’s miles, laps, steps or something else. Donors can pledge a dollar amount for each unit completed. In a monthly mileage challenge, a runner might set a goal of 50 miles, and a donor who pledges $2 a mile gives $100 when the runner hits it.
Charity bib programs with RegFlow. RegFlow is the only end-to-end charity bib management tool. Nonprofits collect applications, sort and rank applicants, and invite the runners they pick to fundraise for a specific race. They can set fundraising minimums and manage each runner through race day, whether it’s a half marathon, a marathon or another event.
GiveSmart: Walks, runs, and rides run through the peer-to-peer module, covering dynamic runs, walks, and other miles-for-mission events.
Participants get branded pages, teams, thermometers, and text-to-donate keywords, using the same setup applied to galas and golf outings.
Verdict: Pledge It, and comfortably. Endurance is built as its own product here, with pledge-per-mile mechanics, fundraising minimums on tickets, and milestone tracking that a general P2P tool does not replicate.
For nonprofits whose fall and spring seasons run on a signature walk or ride, that shows up in registration numbers and in how much of the work stays manual.
4. Sponsorships
Sponsorships are business contributions to your event or cause, typically traded for recognition such as logo placement, tickets, or naming.
Pledge It: Packages go up for sale on the campaign page itself, with slots tracked as they fill. When a sponsor commits, their tickets are allocated automatically, and their guests are tracked like any other attendee.
Payment tracking and fulfillment live in the same dashboard, and you can add, group, and hyperlink sponsor logos on the page. Sponsors can also fund gift matches during the campaign.
GiveSmart: Sponsorships and tables can be added to ticketing with custom fields, and sponsor recognition runs across event pages and displays. Both paid and in-kind sponsors are tracked, with logo placement handled through the event site.
Verdict: Pledge It. Sponsorship runs as a full workflow here, from selling the package to allocating tickets to tracking payment, with no manual handoff at any stage.
5. Donation Forms and Online Giving
Donation forms and online giving let supporters give directly through your website. A form collects donations, with features like recurring giving, receipts, and fee coverage built in.
Pledge It: Forms are embeddable and work with any CMS, so the same donation experience runs on your site and inside your campaigns. Recurring giving is built in, and donors can cover platform and processing fees at checkout.
Branded tax receipts are sent automatically, and every gift lands on the same dashboard as your event revenue. Small changes matter here, which is why optimizing your donation form is worth the time.
GiveSmart: Donation forms are embeddable and mobile-responsive, with custom fields and support for recurring gifts. A donor portal gives supporters self-service access to their receipts and giving history, and fees can be passed on at checkout.
Verdict: A tie. Both cover the essentials well, with embeddable forms, recurring giving, and donor-covered fees. Neither platform asks you to compromise on year-round online giving.
6. Auctions and Mobile Bidding
Auctions raise funds by having supporters bid on donated items, with the top bid winning. Mobile bidding puts the whole process on guests' phones.
Pledge It: Silent auctions run as a Power-Up inside the campaign, so bidding comes alongside ticketing, sponsorships, and donations rather than in a separate system.
Supporters bid from their phones, receive outbid alerts, and pay when the auction closes. Items, bidders, and totals appear in the same dashboard as the rest of the event, which suits an auction that forms one part of a larger program.
GiveSmart: Mobile bidding has been the core product, covering silent, live, and hybrid formats. Item management includes procurement, smart packaging, and premier items, with max bids, outbid notifications, no-bid reminders, auction leaderboards, and self-checkout.
Verdict: GiveSmart is a good choice here. Auction depth is where the product started, and it holds up for galas where live and mobile bidding carry most of the revenue.
7. Raffles and 50/50 Raffle Software
Raffles come in two forms. Item-based raffles sell tickets for a shot at a specific prize, while 50/50 draws split the pot between the winner and your organization.
Pledge It: Both formats run inside the campaign as a Power-Up, with tickets sold online in advance and at the event itself. You can price entry bundles in tiers, and the pot updates live as tickets sell.
Proceeds land on the same dashboard as tickets, sponsors, and donations, so the raffle total is part of the event total rather than a separate figure to add in later.
GiveSmart: Raffles come alongside voting, games of chance, fixed-price items, and merchandise. They run next to the auction and event pages, which suits an event night built around mobile bidding.
Verdict: A tie, with a slight edge to Pledge It for the 50/50 format and in-campaign ticket sales. GiveSmart's raffles work well alongside live bidding.
Note: Raffle rules vary by state. Some require a license or registration, and a few restrict online ticket sales, so check your state's regulations before you launch.
8. Virtual and Hybrid Fundraising
Virtual fundraising happens fully online, while hybrid pairs an in-person event with a remote audience. Both let supporters register, give, and bid from anywhere.
Pledge It: Campaigns run online by default, so remote supporters can register, fundraise, donate, and bid from anywhere. Live donation displays and a real-time feed keep momentum visible during the event.
GiveSmart: Virtual and hybrid fundraising events have dedicated tooling, including livestream, Backstage production controls, live chat, proxy bidding, and a one-screen experience for remote guests.
Verdict: GiveSmart. For organizations running a genuinely virtual or hybrid event, the broadcast and production tools are purpose-built.
9. Event-Night Support
Event-night support is the help available when your event is running live, and issues need fixing fast.
Pledge It: Support runs through the online help center, with phone, chat, and email available. Annual plans include a dedicated Customer Success Manager who works with you on setup, strategy, and planning in the weeks before the event. Pledge It works with partners that can offer virtual and on-site support.
GiveSmart: Support is available 24/7 by phone, chat, and email, with live event-day assistance on top of it. A Client Success Manager and implementation support are included on both pricing models.
Verdict: GiveSmart. Round-the-clock coverage and event-day assistance matter when something needs fixing while guests are in the room.
10. Donor Management
Donor management is how an organization tracks its supporters and their giving over time, so relationships carry forward from one campaign to the next.
Pledge It: Pledge It is built as event fundraising software, not a CRM. Donor records, transaction history, and participant data live on the dashboard, and integrations push that data into the system you already use.
Bloomerang, Neon CRM, Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud, Raiser's Edge NXT, Kindful, HubSpot, and QuickBooks all connect, along with Mailchimp and Constant Contact for email.
GiveSmart: Donor CRM is part of the platform, with household and group records, custom relationship roles, giving history, and dashboard reporting. Fundraising and donor data sit under one vendor.
Verdict: GiveSmart, if you want your CRM and your event tools from the same provider. Pledge It suits teams that already have a donor database in place.
11. Year-over-Year Fundraising
Year-over-year fundraising is about growing the same event over time instead of rebuilding it from zero each season.
It matters because retention drives growth: it's cheaper and easier to bring back someone who already gave than to recruit someone new.
Pledge It: Each campaign can link to the previous one, carrying last year's participants and donors into this year's event.
From there, automated recruiting lets you message previous attendees with custom outreach, including those who haven't signed up again. Year-over-year analytics compare participants and revenue side by side, so you can see what changed and where.
Participants get the same benefit on their own pages, since past donor lists stay attached and returning fundraisers can re-invite the people who gave last season.
GiveSmart: Dashboard and reporting tools cover donor activity across events, so past campaigns can be reviewed and compared. The emphasis is on reporting the data rather than acting on it through built-in recruitment.
Verdict: Pledge It, and this is where it separates itself. Recruitment of lapsed participants is automated rather than manual, so each year's campaign opens with a warm list.
Final Scorecard
Pledge It and GiveSmart Pricing Compared
Note: Pricing reflects published rates as of October 2026 and is subject to change. Confirm current costs with each provider before deciding.
Pledge It Pricing
Note: Pledge It offers options for donors to cover Stripe and platform fees so most nonprofits take home over 98.5% of what they raise.
GiveSmart Pricing
GiveSmart moved to a two-model structure it calls Flex Pricing. Both models include the full Events and Fundraise platform, and neither publishes a rate publicly.
- Annual Fee Subscription: A fixed yearly fee with no per-transaction charges. Positioned for organizations with steady fundraising volume.
- Pay-As-You-Go: No upfront subscription. A per-transaction percentage covers processing and platform costs, with the rate disclosed at signup.
Both include unlimited events and campaigns, implementation support, 24/7 customer service, and an assigned Client Success Manager.
Winner: Pledge It
Pledge It's economics work best across a calendar rather than a single night. At $1,200 a year, you know the full cost of the platform before your first campaign goes live, and it stays the same whether you run one event or six. Add campaigns, team members, or volunteers. The invoice reads the same.
GiveSmart's structure is reasonable, and the $0 entry point suits organizations still finding their footing. The trade-off is that Pay-As-You-Go ties cost to revenue, so a strong year costs more, and the annual figure only arrives after a demo.
3 GiveSmart Alternatives Worth Knowing
Here are three more options for you to compare for your needs.
Note: Pricing for all three is quote-based and current as of October 2026. Confirm figures directly before committing.
1. DonorDrive
A peer-to-peer platform built for participant-driven programs, now part of Bonterra.

Pros
- Livestream fundraising, DIY campaigns, and mobile fundraising each run as their own solution
- A dedicated charity fundraising app for iOS and Android
Cons
- Built for medium and large nonprofits, so smaller teams may pay for scale they do not use
- Setup and customization can get difficult beyond basic tasks
Pricing: Not published. Contact DonorDrive for a quote based on your organization's size and program needs.
2. GoFundMe Pro
GoFundMe Pro (formerly Classy), acquired and renamed by GoFundMe. It is an enterprise-grade platform covering online giving, crowdfunding, corporate partnerships, and event registration.

Pros
- Unlimited donation pages and forms, recurring giving, and Intelligent Ask Amounts included on every plan
- Access to GoFundMe's donor community
Cons
- Event functionality and Salesforce syncing may lack consistency
- Teams needing auctions and ticketing in the base plan often end up scanning GoFundMe Pro alternatives built specifically for events
Pricing: Custom annual subscription, quoted by sales.
Card processing runs 2.4% plus $0.30 per transaction, with an extra 1% on Amex. PayPal and Venmo start at 2.5% plus $0.30.
3. OneCause
An event and auction platform running since 2008 as BidPal, acquired by Bonterra in October 2025.

Pros
- Mature mobile bidding, with outbid alerts and strong event-night support
- Optional on-site staffing for check-in, bids, and paddle raises
Cons
- Little carries between events, so each one starts close to fresh
- Users may face a learning curve during setup
Pricing: Quote-based, sold as separate product lines.
- Pay-As-You-Go: from $200 upfront plus a capped 5% on funds raised
- Professional Auction & Event: from $2,995 a year
- Text2Give: priced separately, from $495 a year
- Processing fees apply on all plans
Final Call: Pledge It vs. GiveSmart
The right answer depends on how your year is structured.
Auction-led organizations will find GiveSmart capable. Mobile bidding and event-day support are its core strengths.
For many small and midsize teams, the auction represents a minority of total event revenue. Ticket sales, sponsorship commitments, and participant fundraising carry the larger share, and each stream must reconcile with the others.
Pledge It, the complete event fundraising platform, was built for that revenue mix. Registration, sponsorships, P2P, auctions, and merchandise operate within a single campaign.
The participant and donor data then compounds. Each season opens with a qualified list of prior supporters to re-engage.
That is how an annual event becomes a growth program.
FAQs on GiveSmart Alternatives
What is GiveSmart and what does it do?
GiveSmart is fundraising and donor management software for nonprofits, schools, and foundations. It handles auctions and mobile bidding, event ticketing, guest check-in, peer-to-peer campaigns, donation forms, and donor records. The company started in 2011 and now operates under Momentive Software.
Is GiveSmart free?
No, GiveSmart runs two pricing models, and neither is free. The Annual Fee Subscription charges a fixed yearly fee with no per-transaction costs. Pay-As-You-Go has no upfront subscription and instead applies a per-transaction percentage, disclosed at signup.
Is GiveSmart secure?
Yes, GiveSmart processes payments through secure payment processing and states that it does not charge separate merchant fees. For specifics on compliance standards and data handling, request current documentation from their team during a demo.
Who uses GiveSmart?
Nonprofits, K-12 schools, foundations, and associations, with a concentration among organizations running auction-led galas. Teams that need something built more around participant fundraising often look at P2P fundraising event software instead, or at platforms covering both.
What's the best platform to accept donations?
That depends on how you fundraise. If you run a signature walk, tournament, or gala each year, a platform covering registration, sponsors, and participant fundraising in one place will serve you better than a standalone form. Pledge It covers that ground, along with crowdfunding platforms for nonprofit features like live thermometers and real-time donation feeds.
