You've collected the gift baskets, secured the restaurant certificates, and called in a few favors from local businesses. Your auction lineup is coming together, but you're still missing that something extra. Maybe it's a bucket-list vacation, a one-of-a-kind experience, or an item that will really get your guests talking.

There's just one problem: No one's offering to donate it.

The good news? Donations aren't your only option.

Consignment gives nonprofits a way to offer exciting auction items without purchasing them upfront. It's an opportunity to expand your auction lineup, introduce experiences you might not otherwise have access to, and give supporters something new to bid on.

But how exactly does it work? What's the catch? And, most importantly, how much of that winning bid actually goes toward your cause?

Let's get into it.

‍


‍

What Is Consignment?

Consignment is an arrangement in which a third-party provider supplies an item for a nonprofit to offer at its fundraising auction. Rather than purchasing the item in advance, the nonprofit typically agrees to pay the provider a predetermined cost only if the item sells. The nonprofit then keeps the amount raised above that cost.

For example, your nonprofit is planning its annual gala, and you want to offer something beyond the usual gift baskets and restaurant certificates. You find a five-night getaway to Tuscany through a travel consignment provider. The package has an agreed-upon cost of $3,000, but your organization doesn't have to purchase it to include it in the auction.

On event night, the auctioneer introduces the trip, guests start raising their paddles, and the bidding climbs to $5,500. The winning bidder gets a vacation to look forward to, the provider receives its $3,000, and your nonprofit raises $2,500 for your cause.

And if nobody bids? Under the common no-upfront-cost model, your organization simply doesn't purchase the package.

That's consignment in action.

This is the model commonly used for travel consignment items for charity auctions, although it's important to confirm the specific terms with your provider.

Consignment isn't limited to travel, either. Depending on the provider, nonprofits may be able to source sports or entertainment tickets, memorabilia, artwork, one-of-a-kind experiences, and other auction items through similar arrangements.

The key distinction is that a consigned item isn't donated to your organization. It's supplied for your auction under an agreement that determines when and how the provider gets paid.

‍


‍

How Does Auction Consignment Work?

While the details can vary between providers, the consignment process is generally straightforward.

‍

1. Choose Items That Fit Your Audience

Start by exploring available consignment auction items and identifying options that align with your supporters' interests, your event format, and your fundraising goals.

For example, if your audience includes families who enjoy traveling together, a vacation to Orlando with access to its theme parks might be a great fit. On the other hand, if your guests are passionate sports fans, tickets to a major sporting event could generate more interest. The key is choosing experiences that reflect your audience's interests rather than simply selecting the most impressive package available.

‍

2. Review the Provider's Cost and Terms

Each consigned item has an associated provider cost, which is the amount your nonprofit agrees to pay if the item sells under the terms of your agreement.

Before adding an item to your auction, make sure you understand:

  • The provider's cost and when payment is due
  • Whether there are any upfront charges or additional fees
  • What happens if the item doesn't sell
  • Any restrictions, expiration dates, or conditions associated with the item
  • Who is responsible for delivering or fulfilling the item after the auction

For travel packages, this last point is particularly important. You'll want to understand how the winning bidder books their trip, what's included, and whether there are any additional costs they should know about.

‍

3. Set Your Starting Bid and Fundraising Goal

Once you know the provider's cost, you can determine how to position the item in your auction.

Your starting bid is the amount at which bidding begins. Your fundraising goal is the amount you'd like to raise above the provider's cost.

These are two different numbers, and neither should be confused with the item's fair market value.

For example, if a travel package has a provider cost of $3,000, you might set a starting bid of $3,500 and aim for a winning bid of $5,000.

That would raise $2,000 for your organization.

It's also important to establish the minimum amount your organization is willing to accept. Just because an item receives bids doesn't mean it will generate the revenue you're hoping for. Before your event, determine the lowest acceptable selling price and confirm with your provider what happens if bidding doesn't reach that amount.

‍

4. Present and Promote Your Item

Consignment items can be incorporated into live, silent, and online auctions, as well as fundraising raffles, depending on the provider's terms and applicable raffle regulations.

Just like donated items, they need thoughtful presentation. Clear descriptions, compelling images, and accurate information about what's included help supporters understand what they're bidding on or entering for a chance to win.

For a travel package, that means highlighting the destination and experience while also communicating important details such as the number of travelers, length of stay, booking requirements, and any restrictions.

‍

5. Complete the Sale and Fulfillment

If the item sells, your nonprofit collects the winning bid and pays the provider according to the agreed-upon terms.

The provider or another designated party then fulfills the item for the winning bidder.

If the item doesn't sell, nonprofits using the common no-upfront-cost model typically have no obligation to purchase it.

Before your event, confirm how an unsold item is handled and whether any separate fees or commitments apply.

‍


‍

Consignment vs. Donated Auction Items: What's the Difference?

Most nonprofits are familiar with donated auction items. A local restaurant contributes a gift certificate, a business donates a product, or a supporter offers an experience for the organization to auction.

Because the item is donated, the nonprofit doesn't have to pay a supplier to acquire it. The winning bid can go toward the organization's fundraising efforts, less any related expenses.

Consignment works differently because the provider receives an agreed-upon payment when the item sells.

Here's how the two compare:

Donated Items
Consigned Items
How They're Sourced
Contributed by a donor or business
Supplied by a third-party provider
Upfront Purchase
Typically none
Typically none
Cost When Sold
No supplier purchase cost
Agreed-upon provider cost
Money Retained
Winning bid minus related expenses
Winning bid minus provider cost and other expenses
If the Item Doesn't Sell
Organization keeps the item
Typically no purchase obligation under the common model
Scroll to Compare

‍

Does this mean donated items are always better?

Not necessarily.

Donated items can be especially valuable because they allow nonprofits to retain more of the winning bid. They also provide opportunities to engage local businesses, sponsors, and supporters in the fundraising process.

But donations have limitations. Your organization may not be able to secure every type of item it wants to offer, particularly when it comes to travel or other experiences.

Consignment can help fill those gaps.

Rather than choosing between donated and consigned items, nonprofits can use both to create an auction lineup that offers variety, reflects their audience's interests, and supports their fundraising strategy.

‍


‍

When Does Consignment Make Sense for Your Fundraiser?

Consignment can be a useful addition to a nonprofit auction, but that doesn't mean every organization needs it or that every consigned item will be successful.

The best approach is to consider what your auction needs and whether a particular item supports those goals.

‍

When You Want to Expand Beyond Donated Items

Maybe your committee has secured plenty of gift certificates, themed baskets, and local experiences, but you're still looking for a standout item.

Consignment can give you access to options that may be difficult to obtain through traditional donation requests.

A vacation package, for example, could complement your existing donations by introducing a different type of experience into the auction.

‍

When You Want to Avoid Purchasing Items in Advance

Buying auction items outright requires your organization to spend money before knowing whether those items will sell.

With the common no-upfront-cost consignment model, you can offer an item without making that initial purchase.

That doesn't eliminate the need to evaluate its fundraising potential, but it can reduce the financial commitment involved in sourcing auction items.

‍

When You Know What Appeals to Your Supporters

An exciting item isn't necessarily the right item for your audience.

Think about where your supporters live and what might appeal to them. For example, if your nonprofit is based in Maine and your event takes place in the middle of winter, a tropical getaway to the Caribbean could be especially appealing. On the other hand, an organization with a strong community of golf enthusiasts might generate more excitement with a golf getaway to a renowned course.

Before selecting a consignment item, look at what has performed well at previous events. Consider your attendees' interests, preferences, and spending habits.

A well-matched item with a realistic fundraising goal is generally a more thoughtful choice than adding something simply because it's available.

‍

When You Have a Clear Plan for Presenting the Item

Consignment isn't a substitute for auction planning. Your organization still needs to promote the item, highlight what makes it special, and build excitement among supporters.

The good news is that many consignment providers offer marketing materials to help you do just that. Depending on the provider, these might include professional photos, package descriptions, videos, or promotional graphics that can be used in your auction catalog, event presentation, or pre-event marketing.

And when your to-do list is already a mile long, isn't it nice to have one less thing on your plate?

For higher-value items, consider whether a live auction presentation, featured online listing, or additional promotion before the event would be appropriate.

The right approach will depend on your audience, the item, and your overall event strategy.

‍


‍

Can Underwriting Help Cover Consignment Costs?

Absolutely! Underwriting is another option nonprofits can explore when incorporating consignment items into their auctions.

Underwriting occurs when a sponsor agrees to cover all or part of an item's cost, allowing the nonprofit to retain more of the winning bid.

Remember our travel package that cost $3,000 and sold for $5,500? Without underwriting, your nonprofit raises $2,500. But if a business sponsor covers that $3,000 cost, your organization can keep the full $5,500 winning bid, with the sponsor's contribution covering the provider's payment.

But there's another benefit to underwriting that goes beyond the numbers.

Finding sponsors isn't always easy, especially when you're trying to come up with benefits that will get businesses excited about supporting your event. Underwriting a consignment package gives you something specific to offer. Instead of asking a business to sponsor your event in general, you can invite them to sponsor an incredible vacation experience, complete with recognition in your auction materials and a shoutout when the package is presented.

It's a way to make the sponsorship feel more tangible and give businesses a clear picture of what they're supporting.

Of course, underwriting isn't required to use consignment successfully. It's simply another option to consider as part of your fundraising and sponsorship strategy.

‍


‍

What Should You Ask Before Choosing a Consignment Provider?

Not all consignment arrangements are identical, and the provider you work with can influence both your event planning experience and the experience of your winning bidder.

Before committing to an item, ask a few important questions:

  1. What is the total cost to our organization? Understand the provider cost, any additional fees, and when payment is required.
  2. What happens if the item doesn't sell? Confirm whether you have any financial obligations if the item doesn't meet your minimum acceptable bid.
  3. What's included in the item? Review the full description, restrictions, expiration dates, and any expenses the winner may be responsible for.
  4. Who handles fulfillment? Find out who coordinates delivery, reservations, or other arrangements after the auction.
  5. What support is available? Ask whether the provider offers promotional materials, guidance, or assistance before and after the event.
  6. What do other nonprofits and winning bidders say about the provider? Look for reviews and testimonials that speak to the provider's reliability, customer service, and fulfillment experience. Pay particular attention to feedback from winning bidders, since their experience continues well beyond the event.

For travel consignment packages in particular, fulfillment deserves careful attention. A winning bidder's experience doesn't end when they make their payment. They still need to book and enjoy their trip. Choosing a provider with a strong reputation and a track record of positive customer experiences can give your organization greater confidence in that process.

‍


‍

Is Consignment Right for Your Nonprofit?

Consignment can be a valuable tool for nonprofit fundraising, especially when you're looking to expand your auction offerings beyond what you can secure through donations.

But like any auction item, its success depends on thoughtful selection, realistic expectations, and an understanding of your audience.

Before adding a consigned item to your next fundraiser, consider three things: 

  1. Is it something your supporters will want? 
  2. Does the potential revenue make sense after costs? 
  3. Are you comfortable with the provider's terms and fulfillment process?

You don't need to overhaul your entire auction strategy to explore consignment. Starting with one carefully selected item can help your organization understand how the model works and evaluate whether it's something you'd like to use again.

If you're interested in exploring travel consignment for your next fundraising event, Auction Packages offers curated travel experiences with no upfront purchase required and dedicated support for trip winners. And our support goes beyond helping you choose packages. We take a more consultative approach, sharing what we've seen work at other fundraising events, from where to place an item in your auction lineup to tips for presenting it and encouraging bids.

‍